Rymolene’s Pies serves up variety, nostalgia and some surprises
We visited with Margaret Burris, the owner of Rymolene’s Pies in Fayetteville, to talk about an unexpected second career, hundreds of kinds of pie and the customers who have made the shop their own.
Q. How did Rymolene’s Pies get started?
My rule for my kids was they had to have at least some college by the time they were 25. Well they stuck to that, but they reminded me that I didn’t do my two years of college. So I went to Brightwater Culinary School in Bentonville and graduated two months before my 50th birthday. I had a career in retail management before that, including working at Fred’s in Farmington. After culinary school, I started baking for Farmer’s Table in Fayetteville. I opened my bakery in January 2018.
Q. You've created hundreds of different kinds of pies over the years. How do you come up with them?
I’m known for the unusual. I’ll find something, make it, tweak it and make it into something else. I don’t have certain pies I make on certain days. I come in and decide what I want to make. But I do get called out if I don’t have coconut cream, something chocolate, something apple every day. And it’s not just sweet pies. I’ve done sloppy joe pot pie, chicken taquito, coconut curry, flank steak and vegetables, tortellini. You name it, I’ll put it in a pie.
Q. What are some of the more unusual sweet pies you make?
One is the Drunken Razorback. It’s an apple pie with three kinds of bourbon and bacon, and it sells really well during Razorback games. My recipes are all in spiral notebooks. I have an apple notebooks, a coconut notebook, two chocolate notebooks, notebooks for different fruits, key lime. I have my recipes, then I’ll tweak it.
I also have people bring their Grandma’s recipe and say, “I haven’t had this since my grandma made it.” I’ll make it for them. I think that’s what I like about pie. For older people, it reminds them of something, and now younger people are discovering it, too.
Q. What do you think keeps customers coming back?
I think a lot of it is that this is their place, too. Probably 90 percent of the stuff in here, customers have brought me. They’ll go on vacation and find something and bring it in, or they’ll have something at home they think belongs here.
A lot of my customers have been with me since I was baking for Farmer’s Table. Some of them, I can’t remember their names, but when they walk in, I know exactly what pie they’re going to order.
Q. What does the holiday season look like at your pie shop?
My husband and I get here at 8 a.m. Monday the week of Thanksgiving and don’t leave until 3 p.m. Thanksgiving Day. I can kind of tell what’s going on by what people order. When everything feels unsettled, people seem to want something traditional. After COVID, when everybody was getting back together, I made so many pumpkin, pecan and sweet potato pies. People wanted something normal, something familiar.